Before we discuss strategy or alliances or the mechanics of the ceasefire, let us be specific about what happened in Minab. On March 3rd, a strike hit a girls' school in the southern Iranian city. More than 170 people died. Most of them were children. The US and Israel denied involvement. No independent investigation has been completed. Those children are still dead.
That is the context in which French President Emmanuel Macron voiced his disapproval of how the Trump administration conducted this war. Macron did not say anything allied capitals had not been whispering since late February. He said it publicly, on the record, and that act of saying it aloud fractured the diplomatic fiction that the Western alliance was unified behind Washington's approach.
A March 3 strike on a girls' school in Minab, Iran killed over 170 people, mostly children. The US and Israel denied involvement. No independent investigation has been completed.
Verified
The fracture was predictable. Trump launched the war without consulting NATO allies. The administration bypassed the kind of coalition-building that preceded the Gulf War in 1991 and the intervention in Libya in 2011. Those earlier operations had their own moral costs, but they carried multilateral authorization. The Iran campaign was unilateral from day one, with Israel as the sole operational partner.
“A whole civilization will die tonight. — President Donald Trump, approximately 10 hours before announcing the ceasefire
European governments had specific policy objections. The JCPOA — the 2015 nuclear agreement — was a European diplomatic achievement as much as an American one. France, Germany, and the UK negotiated alongside the US, Russia, and China. Trump withdrew from the deal in 2018 over European objections. European diplomats spent years trying to salvage it. The war made salvage impossible.
Ceasefire talks will take place in Islamabad, mediated by Pakistan, Turkey, and Egypt. No European nation or NATO framework is involved.
Verified
Bipi NewsReal-Time, Evidence-Based News Reports
Unlimited access to your personalized investigative reporter agent, sourcing real-time and verified reports on any topic. Your personalized news feed starts here.
Create Free AccountMacron's criticism also reflected alarm at Trump's rhetoric. A sitting American president told the world that 'a whole civilization will die tonight.' European leaders heard that statement and recognized the language of collective punishment — a category of action that violates the Geneva Conventions and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. France is a signatory to both. The US is not a member of the ICC, but France's legal obligations differ. Macron could not remain silent without appearing to condone a threat that his own country's legal framework classifies as criminal.
The JCPOA (2015 Iran nuclear deal) was negotiated by France, Germany, UK, US, Russia, and China. Trump withdrew in 2018 over European objections.
Verified
The Strait of Hormuz closure compounded the economic dimension. European energy markets depend on Gulf oil transiting that waterway. Iran's Revolutionary Guard turned back three vessels. Oil and gas prices had been climbing since the war began. European consumers paid higher prices at the pump while their governments had no seat at the negotiating table. Macron's frustration was policy-driven as much as moral.
“The level of incompetence is both stunning and heartbreaking. — Sen. Chris Murphy, on Iran retaining Strait of Hormuz control
Senator Chris Murphy identified the strategic cost from the American side: allowing Iran to retain leverage over the Strait was, in his words, a 'history-changing win' for Tehran. Murphy is a Democrat criticizing a Republican president, so discount for partisanship. But the argument holds regardless of who makes it. A war that began to project strength ended with Iran controlling the most important chokepoint in global energy.
Bipi NewsThink Further on BIPI.
Where seeking the truth is a journey, not a destination.
Learn moreThe ceasefire talks will take place in Islamabad, mediated by Pakistan, Turkey, and Egypt. Notice who is absent from that list. No European mediator. No NATO framework. The Western alliance that defined transatlantic security for 75 years is not at the table for the most consequential negotiation of 2026.
Laura Loomer, a far-right activist close to Trump, predicted the ceasefire 'will fail' and said the US 'didn't really get anything out of it.' Mark Levin, a pro-Israel commentator with ties to the president, said the war is not over. These voices carry weight in Trump's political orbit. If the ceasefire collapses, the same allied fractures will deepen. Europe will face the choice of supporting a war it did not authorize or breaking publicly with Washington.
History rewards restraint. The Cuban Missile Crisis ended because Kennedy chose the naval blockade over the air strike. The JCPOA succeeded because six nations spent years in patient negotiation. De-escalation in every case required multilateral coordination and the willingness to absorb political cost for long-term stability.
What happened instead was a president who threatened to end a civilization, bombed a girls' school, bypassed his allies, and then declared a ceasefire as if the preceding five weeks were a successful negotiating tactic. Macron spoke because someone had to. The 170 children in Minab cannot speak for themselves.
